Newsletter · · 3 min read

Your Certainty Is Making You Anxious: How civilisation became a machine for laundering uncertainty

Your Certainty Is Making You Anxious: How civilisation became a machine for laundering uncertainty
Photo by Taras Chuiko / Unsplash

There's an easy allure certain things. You like the train that runs on time. The interaction that goes as planned. The computer system that works predictably.

You may also be aware that luck, serendipity and 'upside' lie in the gaps that certainly leaves. Chance and opportunity only exist in uncertain places.

It's becoming more popular to say that uncertainty should be embraced.

You may hear it from your favourite entrepreneur, your life coach, or your therapist. It's a new gospel: learn to sit with the unknown, get comfortable with discomfort, surf the waves of chaos. I have a chapter or so dedicated to this idea in my book, Sovereign.

This frame, in isolation, is fine advice. But the commonly shared version of it misses a crucial truth about us humans. We are not, by nature, creatures tolerant of uncertainty. In fact, we conspire against it. We actively seek to conquer and destroy it.

The entire project of civilisation can be seen as a war against ambiguity.

Agriculture was our first great machine for killing uncertainty, replacing the whims of the hunt with the predictability of the harvest.

Common law, and codified doctrines dating back to Babylonia with Hammurabi, are likewise systems for making social outcomes less random.

Science is designed to formalise the unseen world by turning mysteries into models.

Civilisation is, most simply, a machine for manufacturing certainty.

In our time, this machine has gone into overdrive. Think of the simple act of navigating to a new address.

A decade ago, this involved uncertainty: interpreting a map, getting lost, asking for directions. Today, a GPS launders this complex, probabilistic reality into a single, certain blue line. We outsourced the discomfort and, in doing so, lost the skill. We can follow the line, but if the icon is millimetres askew, we're easily lost.

This is the great, invisible process of our age; I call it Uncertainty Laundering. We feed the raw, chaotic data of the world into our technological and financial systems, and they spit out clean, predictable, packaged products.

An insurance policy launders the terrifying possibility of a house fire into the certainty of a fixed monthly premium. An index fund launders the wild volatility of individual stocks into the smooth, predictable abstraction of "the market." In technology an API call launders the chaotic complexity of a billion lines of code into a single, reliable result.

The problem is, we've become addicted to the output. We live in the filtered, buffered, artificially certain world these systems create. And it has made us fragile. Our innate capacity to handle raw reality has atrophied, like an astronaut's muscles in zero-g.

This leads to the great paradox of modern life:

We inhabit the safest, most predictable, and most certain era in all of human history, yet suffer from more anxiety than any generation before us.

That anxiety isn't a fear of the unknown. It's the vertigo we feel when our systems of artificial certainty fail. It's the systemic shock when the GPS glitches, the market crashes, the supply chain breaks, or the algorithm gives a result that makes no sense. It's the terror of being confronted with an unlaundered world, having forgotten how to process it.

The ancient Stoics practised "voluntary discomfort" to prepare for fate in a world where uncertainty was the raw, unprocessed baseline. Our challenge today is different. We don't need to practise for raw reality—we need to re-acquaint ourselves with it entirely.

We must re-learn how to read the world in its native tongue. A capricious one. One of wild whimsy. Where luck and serendipity are bountiful, but only when sought.

Our anxiety isn't a fear of the unknown. It's a withdrawal symptom. We've built a world that launders uncertainty into a comfortable fiction, and now we've forgotten how to live in reality.

Read next

CTA